Serendipity Market and Bakery

2810 St Marys Rd, St Marys, GA 31558, United States
+1 912-882-2253
$$$ Cafe
(21 Reviews)
Price Range $50–100

Serendipity Market and Bakery in St Marys feels like the kind of neighborhood cafe where familiarity grows with each visit. More than just a spot for coffee and sweets, it unfolds as a casual hub for locals looking to grab a thoughtful meal or a dessert crafted with care. The air of a small-town bakery melds here with a quiet energy—perfect for a mid-morning treat, a lunch break, or picking up a comforting casserole for dinner.

The menu balances fresh, daily specials and grab-and-go casseroles, which suggests it’s a place many rely on for convenience without skimping on flavor or home-style satisfaction. Options like a Vegan Mexican Grain Bowl alongside heartier chicken and cheese-heavy dishes show a versatility that caters to different tastes and dietary preferences. This range makes it easy to step in whether you want something light or a filling meal to take home.

Cupcakes draw a steady flow of sweet lovers, evident from the variety and consistent praise from customers who often note both the creativity in flavor and quality in gluten-free options. The bakery’s ability to handcraft special occasion cakes—wedding and anniversary orders come up often—adds a layer of trust that locals place in their cakes not just as treats but as part of meaningful moments.

Visitors should expect a welcoming, unpretentious atmosphere with a hint of personal connection, where the owner’s flexibility and responsiveness come through clearly. People in St Marys seem to come here for the friendly interactions as much as the food, whether it’s arranging a last-minute dessert order or sharing a meal to brighten someone’s day. The crowd likely includes regulars stopping by mornings or afternoons for a coffee and cupcake fix and families or busy professionals pre-ordering meals to ease their evenings.

For those visiting or passing through St Marys, Serendipity Market and Bakery provides a genuine slice of local life—a place where artisan baked goods meet everyday practicality, and the community’s quieter celebrations find their sweetest accompaniments.

Highlights
Great coffee
Great dessert
Popular for
Solo dining
What they serve
Coffee
Comfort food
Quick bite
Best for
Dessert
Accessibility
Wheelchair-accessible car park
Wheelchair-accessible entrance
Wheelchair-accessible seating
Wheelchair-accessible toilet
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot

Openings Hours

Checking

Monday

Closed

Tuesday

10:30 AM - 06:30 PM

Wednesday

10:30 AM - 06:30 PM

Thursday

10:30 AM - 06:30 PM

Friday

10:30 AM - 06:30 PM

Saturday

10:30 AM - 02:00 PM

Sunday

Closed

21 Reviews
Calli Jones

24 Dec 2025

We hired Ashlyn for our wedding cake & desserts and we couldn't be more pleased. Not only was she able to provide a beautiful white & glitter cake for us, she also made individual vanilla cheesecakes and two different kinds of cupcakes for our guests. She had many flavor and frosting options to choose from, and we had a last minute change to our entire order and she was SO kind to facilitate that for us! The cake we ordered was moist and delicious and had incredible flavor. It was so hard to pick a favorite from the different options we chose-- Kahlua Fudge, White Chocolate, Pound Cake w/ Frangelico Icing. Everyone spoke very highly of our desserts and thankfully we ordered heavy enough that we were able to save some and take them home! Even after being stored in the refrigerator for 2 weeks after the wedding, the cake still tastes delicious! We can't wait to receive our photos so we can post how simple and beautiful our cake was. For all of the work she did for us, she is very reasonably priced and we would highly recommend her for your next event. Thank you!

Christy Thomas

22 Dec 2025

This is my favorite bakery of all time. The craftsmanship and artistry in her cakes and cupcakes are amazing. She makes amazing gluten free cakes too! Her grab and go dinners have been favorite gifts since she opened. Know someone having a bad day? You can't go wrong with a card and a meal from here.

cedrix scott

03 Dec 2025

I ordered for the 1st time through DoorDash today 2/16/24 because I had a sweet tooth. And man when I tell you these cupcakes were delicious!!!!!! I will definitely be visiting the store asap.

Mallory Hammock

17 Nov 2025

Placed an order over the phone for a birthday cake delivery. They did an outstanding job! The cake was beautiful, definitely a talented decorator and was delivered on time. Thank you so very much and I didn't get to taste but was told it was delicious also!

deb oconnell

09 Nov 2025

i cant gush enough about this bakery !!! our 25th anniversay cake was absolutely beautiful and delicious!!!!i would 100 % recommend this bakery.She was so easy to work with and her cake was beautiful. thank you for your lovely talent.:)

Mary Jane Brooks

02 Nov 2025

My first time. Ordered a whole tomato pie, curry chicken salad , gumbo and cupcakes for a family dinner. All were five star. Service was great. All to go and take home to heat up. Wonderful Friday night supper at home.

WhitWhit Davis

14 Oct 2025

Not only her services on point, but her cookies are so DELICIOUS. I haven't had much of all but the heath cookies I've fell in love with!! I cannot wait to try other products. Give her a try, pretty certain you won't be disappointed.

Robert Williams

30 Sep 2025

The cupcakes are quite delicious, but their meals are really where it's at. The vegetable lasagna tonight made our evening after a rough day. Thank you! We also really appreciated that the packaging was foil and paper instead of plastic.

Join the Serendipity Market and Bakery Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.